Follow 2018 With The Cook Political Report
We often get asked what signs or numbers we watch to make our 2018 predictions. So we compiled a list of some of the most salient polls and data that we think are the best measures the national political mood.
But sure to bookmark this page. We will update it as new numbers are available.
If you're not already a subscriber, we hope you follow 2018 with us and subscribe today.
1. Presidential Approval
The #1 number that we are checking every day is President Trump's approval rating. It's pretty simple — the lower the president's approval ratings, the more likely it is that the president's party will lose seats in Congress. This is why when there is a very unpopular president, we usually see a wave.
This week Gallup listed President Trump's approval rating at 35%, with 60% disapproving.
Gallup: Weekly Trump Approval
History tells us that the president's party will lose seats in midterm elections. In the House, the president’s party has lost seats in 35 out of 38 elections (92%) since the end of Civil War. In the Senate, the president's party has lost seats in 19 out of 26 elections (73%) since the 1913 (17th Amendment).
When the president is popular (an approval rating of 60% or more), his party has lost, on average, a handful of seats. When it is between 50-60%, the party of the White House has lost an average of 12 seats in the House and one in the Senate. But, when the president's job approval rating is under 50 percent, the party in the White House has lost, on average, 40 House seats and five Senate seats. Trump's approval rating remains under 50 percent (it has hovered between 32-45 for his first term), it does not bode well for Republicans in 2018.
Historic Presidential Approval Ratings and Seats Lost
Midterm election results have gotten even more volatile in the last 25 years. Four out of the last six midterm elections have resulted in the House, the Senate or both changing parties. In the last six midterm elections, the only years in which the President’s party did not lose either their House or Senate Majority, were 1998 (during Clinton’s impeachment backlash) and 2002 (during the aftermath of 9/11).
Presidential Approval Ratings vs. House Seats Lost
1966 to 2014
More on approval:
- Charlie Cook: Will Trump Lead Republicans Into Little Big Horn?
- Charlie Cook: Will the 2018 Midterms Follow Historic Patterns?
- Amy Walter: Laws of Political Gravity Dragging Down Republicans
2. Intensity Polling
In addition to tracking Trump's disapproval ratings, we closely watch the number of people who strongly disapprove. It’s not just Trump's disapproval, but the intensity of disapproval that should be very concerning for GOP. Elections are about motivation. And, anger or dissatisfaction is a very powerful motivator.
Gallup asks just the basic approve-disapprove question. But other pollsters try to measure intensity, asking those who approve whether they strongly or only somewhat approve and those who disapprove whether they strongly or only somewhat disapprove.
Those who strongly disapprove of the job Trump is doing as president outnumber those who strongly approve his job performance by a 2-1 margin. According to the latest NBC/WSJ polling, 48% strongly disapprove of President Trump and 24% strongly approve.
Intensity Polling: NBC/WSJ
More on intensity:
- Amy Walter: Mixed Messages on Enthusiasm and Engagement
- Charlie Cook: Why Trump’s Approval Ratings Hold Firm
- David Wasserman: 2018 Could Be The Year Of The Angry White College Graduate
3. Congressional Ballot
The "generic ballot" is a poll question that asks voters which party they’d support in the upcoming congressional election. It won't tell us exactly how many seats a party may pick up, but it does show us which party has an advantage.
House Editor David Wasserman thinks Democrats need to win the national House vote by seven to eight-point margin to flip the 24 seats they need to take control of Congress.
Current Aggregate Polling Averages — December 19, 2017
Other Polls to Watch
More on the generic ballot:
In the last three waves, the party that won the House also decisively won the vote of self-described independent voters.
Independent Vote in Midterm Elections
Currently, Trump is polling very poorly with independent voters. Only 31% of them approve of the job he is doing. According to Gallup polling, his highest approval was 42% when he first took office, and his lowest approval point was 29% in early August 2017.
Trump's Approval Among Independents
Going into the last two wave elections in 2006 and 2010, Bush and Obama respectively had terrible approval numbers among independents.
Incumbents are very hard to beat, even in wave years. For example, in the last four House wave elections (1994, 2006, 2008, and 2010), 59% of House incumbents from the president's party that represented a CD with a PVI that favors the other party by 0-5 points, won 59% of the time. In other words, almost two-thirds of incumbents in some of the most vulnerable seats were able to hold onto them, even in a terrible year for their party. But, when those seats were open seats, the president's party held just 6 percent of those seats.
Incumbent Party's Retention Rates in Past Four House Wave* Elections
Subscribers also have access to our list of all open and potentially open seats in the house. Currently, there are 25 open Republican Seats and 13 open Democratic Seats.
6. House Math
Currently, Democrats hold 193 seats and Republicans hold 239 seats in the House. There are three vacancies.
Democrats need to flip 24 seats to take back the house. There are 18 Republican seats rated Toss Up or worse. That means that Democrats would need to win all 18 of those seats and pick off six other seats in the Lean Republican column.
2018 House Race Ratings (Last Ratings Change December 15, 2017)
Realistically, Democrats will not win 100% of the seats in Toss Up or worse. In the last three midterm waves (2010, 2006 and 1994) the out party on average won 71% of seats in the Toss Up or worse column.
How Races in Toss Up or Worse Break in Wave Elections
Our ratings will change significantly over the course of the next year. But it's important to keep an eye on the number of seats we have in the Toss Up column.
7. Senate Math
After Democrats blockbuster win in the Alabama special election, Democrats only need two seats to take the Senate. There are three Republican seats in the Toss Up column: Arizona, Nevada, and Tennessee.
While it's possible for Democrats to win the two seats they need, it will also be an uphill battle. Democrats are defending 26 seats compared to Republicans who are only defending eight. Democrats must also defend 10 seats in states that Trump won. And 5 seats that Trump won by 19 points or more.
Democratic Exposure in the Senate By 2016 Presidential Results
Republican Exposure in the Senate By 2016 Presidential Results
Senior Senate Editor Jennifer Duffy shows that seats in the Toss Up column do not break evenly. One party tends to win a disproportionate share of them.